Blogs

Cybersmear – the Skank Blogger Plans to Sue Google for $15m for Disclosing Her Identity

08.24.09

A recent ruling about an alleged anonymous slanderous blogs about a New York City model made it to the front page of every news media on the Internet when a New York City Judge ruled that Google had to identify the name of the person who ran the blog called “Skanks of NYC.” When Liskula Cohen (the defamed model ) learned the identity of the anonymous blogger was Rosemary Port, a 27-year-old student at the Fashion Institute of Technology, Cohen decided to not pursue any slander claims against Port. In an interesting turn of events, now Port claims that Google somehow breached a fiduciary duty and Port’s attorney is bringing a claim against Google for $15M.

Internet Anonymity Protection

Without question the First Amendment of the US Constitution provides the right of free speech and citizens can anonymously make public statements with impunity, except if the statements are slanderous, libelous, or violate some law.

What Did the Judge Say?

Cohen filed a lawsuit in January 2009 against the unknown blogger (I assume Jane Doe) and in the normal course of a Cybersmear lawsuit a subpoena was issued to Google to learn the identity of the anonymous blogger. The legal question was whether the anonymous blogger breached the contractual terms of service with Google. If there was a breach by the blogger then the blogger lost their right to anonymity. You have to look at the Google Blog Terms of Service, Privacy Policy, and Content to determine if the blogger violated these terms. Google must have decided that Port violated the contractual terms and then whether her identity became public was up to the New York City Judge.

Apparently Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Joan Madden believed there was slander and wrote in her decision that "the thrust of the blog is that [Cohen] is a sexually promiscuous woman," and accordingly Google was obligated to disclose Port’s identity since Port violated the contract terms with Google.

How Does Cybersmear Work?

Cybersmear cases have been around for a while and often relate to anonymous postings on sites like Yahoo! Finance where people regularly make anonymous statements about stock values, alleged criminal behavior by corporate officers, and you can just image. Generally once the identity of John or Jane Doe is made public the parties work things out, the posting stop, and there are no headlines.

In this instance Port claims the only person on the Internet who saw "Skanks of NYC" blogs was Cohen, and ironically because of Cohen’s lawsuit and the alleged violate by Google of Port’s rights, now everyone on earth knows. I’m sure there a lesson in this case but generally I’m reminded of the New Yorker Cartoon where two dogs are talking and one says to the other “I had my own blog for a while, but decided to go back to pointless, incessant barking.”

The publications contained in this site do not constitute legal advice. Legal advice can only be given with knowledge of the client's specific facts. By putting these publications on our website we do not intend to create a lawyer-client relationship with the user. Materials may not reflect the most current legal developments, verdicts or settlements. This information should in no way be taken as an indication of future results.

Search Tips:

You may use the wildcard symbol (*) as a root expander.  A search for "anti*" will find not only "anti", but also "anti-trust", "antique", etc.

Entering two terms together in a search field will behave as though an "OR" is being used.  For example, entering "Antique Motorcars" as a Client Name search will find results with either word in the Client Name.

Operators

AND and OR may be used in a search.  Note: they must be capitalized, e.g., "Project AND Finance." 

The + and - sign operators may be used.  The + sign indicates that the term immediately following is required, while the - sign indicates to omit results that contain that term. E.g., "+real -estate" says results must have "real" but not "estate".

To perform an exact phrase search, surround your search phrase with quotation marks.  For example, "Project Finance".

Searches are not case sensitive.

back to top